Report gives state’s transit system grade of D-
Pennsylvania’s infrastructure receives a C-
Trending
A new report by a civil engineers' group gives Pennsylvania a C- grade for the state of the state's infrastructure.
The group flagged the state's underfunding of mass transit as contributing to the lackluster grade. That soon could change. Democrats, who enter 2027 with a trifecta of power in Harrisburg, say mass transit funding will be a top priority in the upcoming legislative session.
The 2025 Report Card for America's Infrastructure, produced by the American Society of Civil Engineers, gave Pennsylvania a D- for the state of its transit system, the lowest grade the group gave to any segment of the state's public infrastructure. In its last report card, the engineering group gave Pennsylvania's transit infrastructure a D grade.
Since then, the state's transit funding crisis has led to cuts in services in agencies big and small around Pennsylvania.
"Many transit agencies are experiencing operating deficits and have increasingly relied on capital funds to sustain service. In 2025, Pittsburgh Regional Rail (PRT) faced a $100 million budget shortfall and proposed major service reductions and fare increases, while the Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (SEPTA) was authorized to use $394 million in capital assistance to support operations," according to the report. "Without dedicated funding streams to make up the loss of other programs, agencies across the state face service cuts and system scale backs. Future improvements, upgrades, safety measures, and expansions remain out of reach, especially if capital funding continues to be used for systems operations."
The report notes that while vehicle travel has fully rebounded since the COVID-19 shutdowns, transit ridership has not. Before the pandemic, 5.7% of Pennsylvania relied on transit to commute to work while 7.1% of urban workers relied on transit. The new data shows that only 4.2% of Pennsylvania workers and 5.3% of urban workers say they use transit to commute.
The number of transit vehicles operated by Pennsylvania's 74 transit systems dropped by 900 from 2020 to 2024, according to the engineer group's report.
"More recently, several agencies have taken drastic measures to offset losses, sometimes cutting over 20% of all service," the report said, adding that both SEPTA and the Pittsburgh transit system warned in 2025 that they might have to implement draconian service cuts. Those service reductions were avoided but transit officials are still eyeing potential cuts, the report said.
Pittsburgh Regional Transit is in the late stages of complete review of all bus routes, including plans to discontinue 20 routes, add 14 new lines and modify almost all existing routes.
"While PRT claims that 99.2% of residents will still have a bus stop within a quarter mile of their residence, many residents, especially those on the periphery of the urban area, will see reductions in service in the form of reduced frequencies and more transfers," according to the report. "Meanwhile, areas such as Oakland, which are more affluent and have high transit ridership thanks to several nearby universities, will see service increase. This triage, while it may attract new riders, also disenfranchises communities where transit already served a key role."
Strategies to boost funding
While the governor and Democratic leaders have made it clear they intend to make transit funding a priority, they have not specifically outlined how they will tackle the problem.
Shapiro has repeatedly said he would like to increase the amount of sales tax directed to transit funding -- from the current 7.68% to 9.43%. In prior year budget proposals, Shapiro's administration has estimated that would generate about $300 million a year in additional transit funding.
Advocates say they support Shapiro's plan but it does not go far enough.
Legislation introduced in both chambers of the General Assembly would increase the tax on rental cars and create a statewide tax on ridesharing revenue to generate the needed funding.
Advocates say the measures will generate nearly $700 million, enough to restore funding levels for the state's major urban transit systems to pre-COVID-19 levels and boost funding for rural transit systems by 10%.
House Bill 1524 would more than triple the daily tax charged on car rentals -- bumping the tax from $2 a day to $6.50 a day.
House Bill 1523 would require ridesharing companies to pay 4.6% on their gross receipts for rides in Philadelphia and 6% on rides elsewhere in the state. Rideshares in Philadelphia have been subject to a 1.4% tax for a decade.