Trending
The state Board of Education rejected proposed changes to the Pennsylvania statewide standardized testing score cutoffs Thursday.
"The purpose is to ensure that performance labels accurately reflect what students know and can do, but not to make assessments easier or harder," said Amy Lena, deputy secretary for the Office of Elementary Education for the state Department of Education.
The proposal would have impacted how the state evaluates student proficiency, lowering the cutoff thresholds -- "below basic, basic, proficient or advanced" -- for the Pennsylvania System of School Assessment (PSSA) and the Keystone Exam.
The decreased thresholds would have made it easier for students to fall into the "advanced" category.
"It doesn't mean that they're necessarily ready to jump into a skip a level. It means that they know that grade level of content ... and are ready for additional challenging content," Lena said.
The measure failed in a 9-5 vote. If the changes would have passed, they would have retroactively applied to PSSAs and Keystones that students took in spring 2026.
Students are still awaiting these standardized testing results from the 2025-26 school year. Teachers and administrators typically rely on the scores to determine appropriate course placements at the start of each school year, but the delay has complicated that process.
Critics argued the proposed changes would muddy student achievement data used to determine state funding for public schools across Pennsylvania.
"Pennsylvanians should be highly suspect of the proposed test score changes," said Rachel Langan, policy analyst for the Commonwealth Foundation. "Not only is Pennsylvania continuously lowering the bar for student success, but obscuring key data points that compare current student achievement to that of previous years."
The PSSAs measure mastery of academic standards in English and Math for Pennsylvania students grades 3 through 8, while the Keystones evaluate high school students before graduation on Algebra,
Literature and Biology.
The proposal was an attempt to change the scoring metrics for the first time since the implementation of Pennsylvania's Core Standards in 2015.