Trending
The Independent Fiscal Office has repeatedly warned that Pennsylvania lawmakers have faced structural deficits as they plan for the state budget only to have the final spending package approved and balanced with one-time tricks or unexpectedly robust tax revenue.
This year is different, the IFO's director Matt Knittel told reporters on a Thursday afternoon press call.
The state is out of couch cushions to find unspent dollars and it's unlikely that tax revenues will be able to make up the difference, he said.
"The one-time transfers and the delays and shifts have largely been used up. The COVID funds have been largely used up, and the general fund surpluses exhausted," Knittel said.
"This time, it is different and we do feel that permanent changes will be required."
The IFO's current projection for 2027-28 is that spending will likely outpace revenues by $6.65 billion unless lawmakers approve policy changes that generate more state tax dollars.
That structural deficit estimate factors in expected increased costs to continue to respond to a 2025 court decision that found the state has been unconstitutionally short-changing students in less wealthy school districts, he said. It also includes expected increased costs for the Department of Human Services.
The IFO warning comes days after Democrats emerged from the midterms with majority control of both chambers of the General Assembly and Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro poised to begin his second term in office.
Shapiro has already indicated that he wants Democratic lawmakers to use their trifecta to raise the minimum wage.
It's not the only opportunity for new revenue available for lawmakers. Almost every neighboring state, except West Virginia, has legalized adult recreational marijuana.
The IFO estimated in February that the state would have generated $140 million in revenue from marijuana legalization if the proposal had been included in the 2026-27 budget.
Legalizing and taxing skill games could generate a more substantial sum -- the IFO estimated that the state would generate $487 million in the first year with 40,000 games taxed at 52%, as Shapiro proposed in his 2026-27 budget. However, Knittel noted that the accuracy of that projection would depend on how many skill games are returned to service once the existing ban ends. Skill games have been illegal in Pennsylvania since Oct. 13 when a court decision deeming the devices illegal slot machines took effect.
The IFO estimates that the state would net about $25 million in tax revenue by raising the minimum wage. Shapiro's budget proposal projected that increasing the minimum wage would generate $80 million in additional tax revenue and cut Medicaid spending by $300 million as workers moved out of the program.