Breaking News
Local News

Moshannon Valley ICE Processing Center detainee loses attempt to speed release

By Phil Ray 3 min read

An immigrant from Colombia housed in the Moshannon Valley ICE Processing Center in Clearfield County has lost his attempt to expedite his release from custody, according to an opinion issued Tuesday by the U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals.

Jair Ramirez, classified as a pretrial detainee, in December filed a habeas corpus petition (a constitutional challenge to his incarceration) in the federal District Court in Johnstown seeking his release from Moshannon Valley.

Ramirez is acting as his own attorney.

Federal court records show that a magistrate judge on Jan. 7 ordered the Ramirez case closed until Ramirez completed the filing of a motion to proceed in forma pauperis, meaning he does not have the financial resources to pay the required filing fee.

However, on Jan. 8, the court records showed he paid a filing fee, and on Jan. 9, now-retired Magistrate Judge Keith A. Pesto ordered the government to serve the papers on the named defendants that include the Department of Homeland Security, ICE headquarters in Philadelphia and the U.S. Attorney General.

While the case was assigned to District Judge Stephanie L. Haines, she referred it for review to Magistrate Judge Richard A. Lanzillo, who presides in Erie.

The case then proceeded through the normal process that included status reports and government responses to the Ramirez habeas petition.

On July 20, many months after Ramirez filed his habeas petition, he filed a motion to expedite his case, and, at the same time, requested a Writ of Mandamus (a more extraordinary proceeding than a habeas petition) seeking an immediate hearing.

In August, Ramirez requested an appointment of a counsel due to his "indigency and unfamiliarity" with the legal process.

The appointment of an attorney was denied by the magistrate judge (Lanzillo) who explained at this point of the proceedings Ramirez is able to articulate his positions during the preliminary phase of his case.

The magistrate judge further explained, "The Court assures (Ramirez) that his case is active and will be addressed in due course."

Meanwhile, the government and Ramirez continued to spar over his habeas corpus petition.

On Oct. 13, a report by Lanzillo to Haines recommended the Ramirez habeas petition be denied.

In early November, Haines reviewed objections by Ramirez to Lanzillo's recommendation.

Also, during that time, Ramirez took his request for a mandamus hearing to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals and asked that his request be expedited.

It was this request that was denied in Tuesday's Third Circuit ruling.

In their opinion, Judges Michael A. Chagares, Thomas M. Hardiman and L. Felipe Restrepo denied Ramirez's mandamus petition.

"A writ of mandamus is a drastic remedy available only in extraordinary circumstances," the court explained.

"Mandamus should not issue unless the petitioner has no other adequate means to attain the relief sought and has shown that his right to the writ is clear and indisputable," the appeals court continued.

Mandamus is warranted when a court's "undue delay is tantamount to failure to exercise jurisdiction."

The Third Circuit opinion, however, concluded Ramirez has not shown that there has been "undue delay" involved with his case.

If his habeas petition is ultimately denied, he has the right to file an appeal, the Third Circuit concluded.

Ramirez's background and facts surrounding his case are not available to the public.

Starting at /week.