Trending
A Blair County judge vacated the 10- to 20-year sentence of the city man convicted in May 2023 on felony offenses associated with a fistfight and stabbing.
Gordon Louis Perry, 44, was convicted by a jury on felony counts of aggravated assault and escape, as well as misdemeanor counts of possession of an instrument of crime and making terroristic threats. He was then sentenced by former-President Judge Elizabeth A. Doyle in August 2023 to 10 to 20 years' incarceration in a state correctional institution.
The case was brought against Perry after he brought a knife to a fistfight in July 2022 and left the victim with abdominal wounds that required three layers of internal stitches. At trial, Perry tried to convince the jury that his actions were in self-defense.
Judge Louis C. Schmitt issued an order in August 2026 granting a post-conviction relief act petition filed by defense attorney Stephanie Noel and vacating Perry's sentence.
In the petition, Noel requested the sentence's vacation and the awarding of a new sentencing hearing. Noel argued that as Perry "had not been 'arrested or detained on a charge of felony'" and "had only been subjected to an investigative detention for then-unknown offenses at the time he fled from a police officer," his felony escape charge should have been graded as a misdemeanor.
Noel wrote that Perry's trial counsel had been ineffective under both the state and U.S. constitutions "for failing to object to and correct the grading." She further argued that the statutory maximum sentence for that misdemeanor is two years, therefore the sentence imposed at that count by Doyle was "illegal."
After Schmitt handed down his order granting the petition, assistant district attorney Julia Wilt filed a notice of appeal to the state Superior Court on Nov. 6.
Prior to filing the appeal, Blair County District Attorney Pete Weeks filed a motion for reconsideration on Nov. 3. Weeks argued that Doyle addressed the grading of the escape charge at the time of sentencing, during which she said Perry's actions "were not peaceable, they were not law-abiding, they were not conforming with behavior that was required in the presence of the police and the jury found that they rose to the level of escape."
Weeks wrote that the Superior Court agreed that the appeal Perry filed immediately after his sentencing was "wholly frivolous" and upheld Perry's sentence.
Perry then filed a PCRA petition, which was granted by Schmitt despite not holding an evidentiary hearing on the matters raised, Weeks wrote.
"There is nothing of record to support the granting of the PCRA petition," Weeks wrote. "The Commonwealth respectfully asks for this matter to be re-listed for evidentiary hearing on the effectiveness of trial counsel so that a record may be created."
Noel then filed an objection to Weeks' motion, writing that the matter had been scheduled for an evidentiary hearing on Aug. 28. At that time, Wilt "chose not to contest Mr. Perry's claims for relief," therefore making the hearing unnecessary.
Noel asked the court to deny Weeks' motion, writing that it was also "untimely" as it had been filed Nov. 3, which was three days before Perry's re-sentencing hearing and "nearly two months after" Schmitt handed down his order.
"The Commonwealth's untimely motion to reconsider, filed far outside of its appellate window, does not reset or extend its deadline to seek reconsideration by this court or appellate review by the Superior Court," Noel wrote.
The case now awaits a decision from the Superior Court. Perry remains imprisoned at SCI Camp Hill.
Mirror Staff Writer Rachel Foor-Musselman is at 814-946-7458.