Pennsylvania Superior Court rejects inmate’s bid to vacate lengthy sentence
King serving 55 to 110 years in prison for sex abuse of a minor
Trending
A Johnstown man this week lost his attempt to have his prison sentence of 55 to 110 years vacated by the Pennsylvania Superior Court.
The defendant, David M. King, who is now 50 years old, was sentenced more than nine years ago by Cambria County Judge David Tulowitski to serve his lengthy sentence after a jury found him guilty of 54 counts of sexual abuse of a minor.
The incidents of sexual abuse occurred over a 10-year period.
Since his sentence in 2017, King has filed multiple appeals under Pennsylvania's Post Conviction Hearing Act.
His latest appeal, King argued, was not filed under Pennsylvania's PCRA law which governs most post-conviction petitions.
Instead, King contended his trial attorney and the prosecution committed a fraud on the court when the sexual abuse charges were brought against him.
He complained he was not granted a formal arraignment and he did not have the opportunity to waive a preliminary hearing, thereby sending his case to the County Court of Common Pleas for trial.
A Superior Court panel that included Judges Mary Jane Bowes, Judith F. Olson and Mary P. Murray in their opinion this week explained that Pennsylvania's PCRA law was established to hear pleas of those convicted of crimes concerning alleged constitutional violations, claims of ineffective counsel or other questions that may have led to improper convictions,
The Superior Court judges noted, however, that there is a time limit of one year from the date a defendant's case becomes final to raise further questions under the PCRA statute.
King's case became final in January 2019 when his time for seeking review by the United States Supreme Court expired.
His present petition was not filed until late October 2025, thus rendering it "facially untimely," the Superior Court panel concluded.
King argued that his petition was not filed under the PCRA law.
He explained that under another statute, the court may hear a case at any time if there is a "showing of fraud or other circumstance so grave or compelling as to constitute extraordinary causes justifying intervention by the court."
King raised the argument that "his counsel and the prosecutor committed fraud upon the court by proceeding with his case without holding a formal arraignment in accordance (with Pennsylvania law) or obtaining his signature on a written waiver."
Cambria County Judge Michael A. Carbonara dismissed his claim without a hearing.
The Superior Court panel in its analysis of the King argument rejected his view that the latest petition does not fall under the PCRA statute.
It took the side of the prosecution which answered King's argument by pointing out, "Simply stating that the motion (to vacate) is not a PCRA petition does not make it so."
The Superior Court opinion explained that when a suspect is charged with a crime, an arraignment is authorized to formally identify the suspect, inform him of the nature of the charges, and allow him to enter a plea (guilty or not guilty).
The arraignment process is a right recognized by the Pennsylvania and U.S. constitutions, but, as the Superior Court stated, "defects in the arraignment do not constitute reversible error unless they prejudice the defendant's rights."
The due process challenge (in Kings' case) is "unquestionably cognizable by the PCRA," the opinion explained.
The appeals court emphasized that King knew he did not receive an arraignment since the time of his trial and that his present petition is barred by the one-year time limit for filing complaints under the PCRA statute.
There are three exceptions to the time bar -- governmental interference, a newly discovered fact or recognition of a new constitutional right.
None of those factors apply to the King case, it was determined by the panel.
The panel then rejected King's motion to vacate his conviction and sentence.
King resides in the State Correctional Institution Houtzdale.