Breaking News
Local News

Bail modification denied in alleged bar fight death

Lopez unable to post $1 million bail previously set

By Rachel Foor-Musselman 5 min read

HOLLIDAYSBURG -- A Blair County judge denied further modification of bail Wednesday in the case of a city man charged with third-degree murder following an alleged bar fight in January that left a male victim dead.

Corey Lexus Lopez, 35, initially had his bail denied before it was modified to $1 million at the magistrate level. In addition to felony third-degree murder, Lopez faces four felony counts of aggravated assault and 10 related misdemeanor charges. He has been in custody at the Blair County Prison since his arrest Jan. 4.

The bail hearing before Judge Jackie Atherton Bernard began with defense attorney Daniel Kiss asking Lopez a series of questions regarding his ties to the area and ability to comply with bail conditions. Lopez confirmed that he was unable to post the $1 million bail and that Kiss was court-appointed as he could not afford a private attorney. While Lopez has a criminal history, Kiss said he was free from supervision "for some time."

If released, Lopez said he would stay with his mother in the city and had a job waiting for him.

"I'm willing to do any bail there is, house arrest, anything," Lopez said.

Kiss then presented the court with a letter of support signed by about 50 community members, saying it showed Lopez's strong ties to Blair County. He told Bernard they were not asking for unsecured bail.

"These are very severe charges, there is no doubt of that," Kiss said.

He argued that while Lopez was charged with third-degree murder, it was his understanding that the fatal heart attack suffered by 41-year-old James Dunn was brought about by "the entire situation" and not just the alleged assault.

"Mr. Lopez did not physically break his skull or do something of that nature to cause this man's death," Kiss said.

He described Lopez's bail as being "far too high" and "excessive," saying Bernard could see in the transcript from Lopez's preliminary hearing that "this was not a typical murder" but "more of a circumstantial death."

"He is not asking to just be set free to go about his daily business," Kiss said.

First Assistant District Attorney Nichole Smith disputed Kiss's characterization of the incident, telling Bernard the case was not one of just aggravated assault.

"This was not just one punch to one victim and we're done," Smith said. "There are multiple aggravated assault charges that address multiple people in this case."

Smith said if they were unsuccessful in prosecuting the murder charge, Lopez still faced the aggravated assault charges, which each carried a maximum sentence of 10 years. She told Bernard she had reservations about Lopez complying with the law as he had allegedly fought with police when they arrived on scene.

Smith also raised issues regarding discovery violations in the case, saying there was an ongoing investigation into videos being shown and interviews being done on podcasts. She said Dunn's medical records were also disseminated to individuals who went on to contact his widow.

"I am concerned that if we release the defendant that those violations are only going to increase," Smith said.

Kiss countered these arguments, saying "it is (Lopez's) discovery and if he chooses to share it, it is allowed."

"He can receive discovery and post every page on the internet if he chooses to do so," Kiss said.

As for the medical records, Kiss said HIPAA laws only applied to healthcare providers as an institution, not individuals.

"Certainly there is discovery that I am not happy has made it out to the public," Kiss said.

He told Bernard that he had a feeling as to who leaked the discovery and that discovery was now "locked down," with nothing more being sent out of his office.

Bernard cautioned Kiss that these disseminations could affect jury selection in the case and might force them to look outside their jurisdiction for potential jurors.

"It makes you wonder if he is getting a fair, impartial jury," Bernard said.

Bernard then addressed the letter of support presented earlier, telling Kiss and Lopez's friends and family in the courtroom that it was "an attempt to influence the court."

"There is no place in the judicial system for attempts to influence the court," Bernard said. "They should be very aware that the court will not look favorably on attempts to influence this judge or jury."

Kiss said he would be agreeable to a potential gag order being put in place and that he had explained to Lopez's friends and family that "I am the attorney here and I should be the one making the decisions."

The discovery leaks also violated the Commonwealth's right to a fair trial and jury, Smith said.

Following the attorney's arguments, Bernard denied and dismissed Kiss's motion for bail modification without prejudice.

"We feel bail is sufficient at this point in the case," Bernard said.

Before being taken from the courtroom, Lopez asked Bernard if there was any way she could reconsider as his "mother was struggling." Bernard said Kiss could file another motion in the future.

Lopez's next court appearance is scheduled for Dec. 4 at 8:30 a.m. in courtroom three of the Blair County Courthouse.

Mirror Staff Writer Rachel Foor-Musselman is at 814-946-7458.

Starting at /week.