Breaking News
Local News

Attorney: SCI Houtzdale suicides escalate

Legal representative for inmate’s estate says incidents on the rise at SCI Houtzdale

By Phil Ray 4 min read

An attorney representing the estate of a Philipsburg man who in 2025 committed suicide while incarcerated in the State Correctional Institution Houtzdale contends in a federal lawsuit that the institution has in the last three years "experienced a dramatic and alarming escalation in inmate suicides."

Attorney Dylan T. Hastings of Philadelphia last week filed his third lawsuit in the past 13 months concerning inmate suicide -- this one on behalf of a Philipsburg woman whose grandson committed suicide on July 12, 2025, while in his cell at Houtzdale.

Hastings filed the lawsuit on behalf of Paulette J. Spackman, who on July 11, 2025, visited her grandson, Justin Jack Johnson, an inmate.

The 35-year-old Johnson committed suicide while alone in his cell the next day.

Hastings reported in the lawsuit filed in the District Court in Johnstown that Johnson's cellmate was away from the cell during the afternoon and evening hours.

During that time, Johnson covered the window of his cell and the committed suicide by hanging.

Also during that time, the lawsuit charges, corrections officers supposedly conducted safety checks on the cellblocks where Johnson was housed, but, the lawsuit reported, it was Johnson's cellmate, upon returning to the cell, who found the body.

"For more than 90 minutes, Justin remained alone in his cell with his window completely covered while the correctional officers responsible for his safety repeatedly passed his cell and purported to conduct required security and welfare rounds without ever obtaining a direct visual observation of him," the lawsuit stated.

It contended that at least four rounds of officers passed while Johnson's window was covered.

The officers, it is alleged, took no action to remove the window cover, yet they marked those rounds as "completed," thus visually confirming the inmate was alive and safe, it is charged.

The grandmother's lawsuit points out that since Superintendent David Close took charge of the facility in 2022, the number of suicides has increased.

The lawsuit stated "since Superintendent Close's appointment (in 2022) at least seven other incarcerated persons at SCI Houtzdale also died by suicide, demonstrating a recurring and systematic failure; to adequately identify inmates at risk of self harm, properly train and supervise correctional and medical staff in suicide prevention, conduct required observations and welfare checks, recognize and respond to warning signs of suicidal behavior, communicate critical mental health information among staff, and timely intervene during psychiatric and medical emergencies."

The lawsuit characterized the number of suicides at SCI Houtzdale as reaching "epidemic proportions, evidencing a systematic and institutional failure to protect inmates at known risk of suicide."

Johnson, of Philipsburg, was serving a 5- to 10-year sentence for a burglary that was committed in Clearfield County.

He was a carpenter by profession, but also an individual experiencing mental health problems.

The lawsuit indicated he had been in Houtzdale since 2022.

The defendants include Close and those corrections officers on duty during the afternoon and evening hours of July 12, 2025.

The institution not only has experienced an increase in suicides during Close's time as superintendent, but, the lawsuit emphasizes, Close has been on "notice" of the problem but has failed to provide the proper training and supervision of the staff concerning mental health issues and suicide.

The officers are being sued for their alleged "deliberate indifference" for failing to recognize that an inmate placing a cover over his window "could indicate an increased risk of self-harm."

Hastings has been critical of Houtzdale's failure to address the suicide issues being experienced.

He is the lead attorney on two other suicide death cases involving SCI Houtzdale.

On Feb. 9, 2026, Edward J. Bower Jr. of Lycoming County died while an inmate. Hastings is representing Bower's mother, Tracey A. Watson.

That lawsuit is awaiting a court decision on a motion to dismiss.

The attorney has also filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of Diane L. Kauffman of Coatesville.

Her son, Lance Heverly, 39, of Lancaster County, died by suicide on Nov. 21, 2024.

An amended complaint has been filed in that case.

Starting at /week.