Breaking News
Local News

Altoona Redevelopment Authority prepares to sell Garfield homes

Single-family houses built on site of former elementary school

By William Kibler 5 min read

With help from longtime consultant Winnie Branton of Philadelphia, the city Redevelopment Authority on Friday made several preliminary decisions on how it will go about selling its three newly constructed single-family homes on the former Garfield Elementary School property in Fifth Ward.

The goal is to develop "a fair, transparent and effective process for determining buyer eligibility, selecting qualified purchasers and completing the sale(s)," Branton stated in a memo to board members.

The decisions the board will make formally next month are downstream of requirements that flow from having used American Rescue Plan Act money for many of the materials used in building the homes -- such that they must go to buyers with household incomes no higher than 120% of Area Median Income, and must remain with families at that income level for at least 20 years.

In addition, based on authority policy, buyers must be financially qualified to pay the mortgages they secure, according to Branton's memo.

The board came to informal agreement on selling the home first that is appraised highest, so that the authority can "test the market," while learning whether adjustments need to be made in the process of selling the other two.

The homes are appraised at $232,000, $221,000 and $215,000.

Board members debated whether to accept applications only from first-time homebuyers -- defined as someone who hadn't lived in a home they owned for three years -- but decided informally that for the first home at least, they would not impose such a limit.

They also debated whether to impose restrictions on applications based on where the applicants are currently living.

Some members argued for limiting applications to city or Blair County residents.

But there are people who live elsewhere who grew up in Altoona and would like for an opportunity to return, Branton said.

Board member Matt Pacifico, the city's mayor, went further.

"We want to think big -- cast a wide net -- try to make the city attractive," as recommended by the comprehensive plan, Pacifico said.

Accordingly, members informally agreed that for the first home at least, applicants can come from anywhere.

Eliminating those kinds of restrictions should maximize the response, giving the authority an idea of the overall "pool" of potential applicants, according to Chairman Richard Fiore.

Board members agreed informally that only applicants who have been pre-approved for a mortgage would be accepted, and that the choice among applicants should be by public lottery, with a separate and independent lottery for the first house, and another one for each of the other houses -- or the two taken together.

The order in which names come up in the lottery would be recorded, in case the winner or a runner-up drops out or can't continue -- in which case, the next name would be called.

Branton recommended the lottery method over first-come, first-served and a ranking system.

First-come, first-served can "disadvantage otherwise qualified applicants who learn about the opportunity later or need additional time to assemble" an application, while ranking applications "introduces greater complexity and potential subjectivity" and tends to eat up staff time, Branton wrote.

A lottery has been used in similar programs and is suitable for Altoona, given the authority's intention to "establish clear buyer eligibility requirements and offer the properties at fixed prices, based on their independently appraised values," Branton wrote.

Once applicants have demonstrated they're qualified to buy, "there is little benefit (anyway) to introducing additional competitive selection criteria," she wrote.

A lottery offers "equal opportunity," "transparency and public confidence," administrative simplicity" and "consistency and defensibility," she wrote.

The authority, however, needs to ensure there is an open drawing procedure and must limit applicants to one entry per household, she wrote.

The members informally agreed not to limit household size, in keeping with Branton's recommendation.

It's probably safe to assume that applicants will seek a house that is sized to fit their needs, Fiore said.

The members also informally agreed that buyers would need to make a five-year commitment to remain, although with a good reason that is explained in person to the board -- a job offer in another area, for example -- a waiver would be easily provided.

The members also informally agreed to set the price of the first house at the appraised figure, at least as a starting point.

If there are no applicants, the authority could lower the price and extend the application deadline, Branton said.

"This approach recognizes the market value of the properties, supports responsible stewardship of public funds and advances the RA Land Bank's goal of recovering its investment for future community revitalization activities," she wrote. "At the same time, the pricing strategy must support the program's affordable homeownership objectives by ensuring that the homes are financially accessible to a reasonable pool of income-eligible purchasers."

In the Altoona metropolitan statistical area, 120% of the Area Median Income for a one-person household is $77,600; for a two-person household, $88,700; for a three-person household, $99,800; for a four person household, $110,900; and for a five-person household, $119,800.

The homes are 90% complete, according to Eric Luchansky, the city's community development director.

They are being built by Luther Sitework Solutions of Duncansville.

Mirror Staff Writer William Kibler is at 814-949-7038.

Starting at /week.