Education panel concerned by aging populace
Attracting younger people, retaining current residents a priority for state
Trending
BEDFORD -- The number of counties in the state with more senior citizens than people under the age of 20 will double by the end of the decade, according to projections from the Pennsylvania Department of Education and the Center for Rural Pennsylvania.
Attracting younger people to the state and encouraging those already here to stay were among the many topics discussed during the Basic Education Funding Commission meeting held Thursday at Bedford High School.
Kyle Kopko, executive director at the Center for Rural Pennsylvania, spoke during the public event, which was the final stop of the commission's roadtrip across the commonwealth, where they heard testimony regarding the Legislature's funding of the state's 500 school districts.
Kopko shared the population findings from his organization, also stating that numbers suggest the statewide enrollment rate for school-aged children will decrease by almost 7% by the 2032-33 school year.
Commission co-chair Rep. Mike Sturla, D-Lancaster, said that Kopko's projections were "depressing" and alarming.
"It's almost like we've conceded that we're going to be a stagnant state for the next 25 years," Sturla said.
Commission co-chair state Sen. Kristin Phillips-Hill, R-York, said Kopko's testimony was a "wake-up call" for the state.
Kopko told the commission that not all was lost, especially if the Legislature begins taking steps to attract people to move to the state, such as investing in recreation opportunities and promoting higher education institutions, among other strategies.
"I do realize that the population forecasts do look stark, but I'm still optimistic," Kopko said. "Pennsylvania really does have something to offer for everyone."
Keeping teachers in the state was also among the topics discussed. According to Aaron Chapin, president of the Pennsylvania State Education Association, fewer and fewer college students are choosing education as a profession for a multitude of reasons, not the least of which being a perceived lack of pay in relation to the work teachers do. Chapin said that is why the union supports increasing the minimum salary to $60,000 by the 2028-29 school year.
"There are shortages at every level. We should not be having to come up with these creative solutions," Chapin said. "We need to make this attractive, from the salary to the benefits to our pension system."
Chapin said the total cost of the union's proposal would be roughly $577 million.
Mark Price, director of school funding for the PSEA, said the union was suggesting the state would cover the cost for any districts that would be heavily affected by the proposed salary increase.
Phillips-Hill said her concern with the union's suggestions was that the commission was hearing testimony that the student population across the state continues to decline year over year, so it makes it difficult to spend more on teachers when there might not be enough students to teach.
"How do we hit that sweet spot," Phillips-Hill asked. "We want to encourage people to go into education, but we don't want to invest in people who then we are going to say, 'We don't have a big enough student population to continue to employ you.'"
She said the commission wants to be mindful of the long term goals of the state in funding districts, rather than following the strategies of previous iterations of the commission that focused on quick solutions to address immediate needs.
"We're really trying to be mindful of what it will look like over time," Phillips-Hill said. "People who sit in this seat that I'm sitting in now don't take a long term approach; they do what's convenient now and don't think about the future."
Chapin said he appreciated Phillips-Hill's caution and care, but he was concerned that the state was already so deep in a hole with its lack of teachers that it would take generations to catch up if something isn't done very soon.
"We're at the point right now where our school systems are in severe jeopardy," Chapin said. "If we're going to make sure that the public school system is going to be sustainable for the next generation, we needed to do something three, four years ago."
School district mergers and the financial incentives or deterrents of such consolidations was also on tap. Mergers could be useful in situations where one district is running out of building space to teach its students and another is losing students to the point of having buildings that sit empty, the panel said.
While a merger can often save money for districts in the long run, the upfront costs of a consolidation can be pretty high, said Lynne Shedlock, acting executive director for the Pennsylvania Economy League. In the organization's studies and surveys, it found that most districts and families/taxpayers within the districts are resistant to mergers based on losing their school identity and the cost associated with the move. She said the move would need to be organic and come naturally for it to take off.
"This consolidation, merger idea has to come from the community," Shedlock said. "If they feel like someone from the outside is coming in and telling them what to do, they are going to be less likely to want to do it."
If one district's taxpayers are paying lower taxes while another's are paying higher taxes, once a merger takes place, the taxes will even out, meaning that one group will pay more and the other will pay less. That leads to disgruntled community members, particularly the ones paying more, said Patricia Moorhead, director of financial data and analytics for the Pennsylvania Economy League.
"A lot of times that is a barrier," Moorhead said. "The boards are getting the pushback from the taxpayers, 'How come they're getting a tax break and we're not?'"
Following the meeting, state Rep. Jesse Topper, R-Bedford, said he felt better about the direction the state is headed in terms of finding solutions for the funding problems, but also acknowledged that finding something that works for every school district in the commonwealth is a complicated task.
"We know some of these solutions aren't going to be easy," Topper said. "We understand that they are not going to necessarily make everyone happy equally, and yet we also see a path toward a solution."
"One size does not fit all," Topper said.
Mirror Staff Writer Nate Powles is at 814-946-7466.