Two men sentenced in Matthai shooting
Louk gets 15-30 years; Robertson gets 3-23 months for disposing of body
Trending
BEDFORD -- A Bedford County man who shot and killed his cousin last year was sentenced to 15 to 30 years in a state correctional facility, while a second man involved in the disposal of the body was sentenced to three to 23 months behind bars.
Derek Edward Ashley Louk, 30, pleaded guilty to a single count of felony third-degree murder and one misdemeanor count of abuse of a corpse in the shooting death of 26-year-old Tyler John Matthai. According to the plea agreement Louk took in August, District Attorney Dwight Diehl did not prosecute him on two misdemeanor abuse of corpse charges in a separate but related case.
During sentencing Friday, President Judge Travis Livengood ordered Louk to pay restitution of $5,000 and a DNA fee of $4,500. Incarcerated since his arrest on May 14, 2022, Louk will receive credit for time served.
Jordon Alexander Robertson, 20, pleaded no contest to a misdemeanor charge of abuse of a corpse in exchange for all remaining charges against him to be dropped. Livengood ordered him to pay a fine of $500 in addition to serving his sentence at the Bedford County Correctional Facility.
Both Louk and Robertson were taken into custody after the judge imposed their sentences.
Louk killed Matthai on April 26, 2022, and police received a tip in May of that year about the incident. During the investigation, Louk admitted to shooting Matthai with an AR-15 rifle after he allegedly witnessed Matthai abusing his girlfriend, Courtney Shianne Boden. Boden, 25, was sentenced in May after pleading guilty to abuse of corpse and tampering with/fabricating evidence. She is serving 27 months to 12 years in a state prison and has been ordered to pay restitution of $1,290 to the state crime lab.
Louk said he knew Matthai was dead and enlisted Boden and Robertson to help dispose of the body, court documents show.
Senior Deputy Attorney General David Gorman said during Robertson's plea court hearing in July that Robertson had indicated during an interview that "Boden had contacted (Robertson) to dispose of 'something.'"
"(Robertson) helped put Matthai in the bed of a truck to take to Louk's property," Gorman said.
It was there that the trio burned and buried Matthai's body, Gorman said.
During Robertson sentencing Friday, Matthai's mother and sister, Michelle and Kae Flamm, respectively, were given the chance to read victim impact statements.
Michelle Flamm alternated between addressing Livengood and Robertson, saying that she was still in denial after 17 months.
"They lit a fire and went to bed and slept," Michelle Flamm said. "How can you sleep after witnessing those horrible things?"
She told Livengood that a misdemeanor charge wasn't enough and asked what Robertson would do in the future "if he was capable of doing those horrendous things at such a young age with no remorse?"
Kae Flamm used her statement to point out that the only reason they knew what happened to her brother was because Robertson told his uncle about it at a gas station.
"It was only because he was blabbing about it like it was nothing, like Tyler was nothing," Kae Flamm said.
The pair also spoke before Louk's sentencing, with Kae Flamm saying that their family used to call her, Matthai and Louk "the Three Musketeers."
"I can't say I hate you," Kae Flamm said. "I should. Please think about what you've done."
Michelle Flamm said that she never dreamed that Louk would be the one to take Matthai away from her, or in the manner that he did.
"He was not trash," Michelle Flamm said. "He was my flesh and blood, my son, a beloved brother. A part of me burned with him."
She said that she still loved Louk and would pray for him and his soul.
When given the opportunity to speak, Louk said that he was "truly sorry."
"I wish I could take it back but what's done is done," Louk said.
Robertson shook his head no when asked if he wanted to make a statement.
Mirror Staff Writer Rachel Foor is at 814-946-7458.