Trending
A federal appeals court on Monday denied further action on a petition by a former inmate in the Federal Correctional Institution at Loretto, who contended his earned time credit had been miscalculated and that he was entitled to home detention rather than placement in a Residential Reentry Management Center.
Atif B. Malik, 55, of Germantown, Md., who had a pain management practice and who, with several other doctors, was arrested for conspiracy to commit tax fraud and for operating a fraudulent billing scheme through Medicare and private insurance companies, argued that he wasn't given enough earned time credit that would have resulted in his release from imprisonment much sooner.
Malik filed a petition in the federal District Court in Johnstown seeking to have his earned time credit recalculated, noting he was classified as a "minimum risk" for reoffending under the First Step Act.
On July 5, Magistrate Judge Patricia L. Dodge denied his petition as moot since his earned time credit had already been recalculated and he was granted 735 days of credit.
In April, Malik was transferred from the prison in Loretto to a reentry center in Baltimore and his release date from an eight-year prison sentence imposed in 2018 is now listed as December of this year.
In her opinion, Dodge rejected a claim by Malik of $2,500-per-day restitution for 735 days he spent in prison prior to the recalculation of his earned time.
Dodge ruled that there is no relief the federal court can provide based on the mootness of his petition.
She also denied his request to serve his time in home detention as opposed to being held in a reentry center.
Malik filed a petition for mandamus with the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia as a challenge to Dodge's July 5 opinion.
A panel of the 3rd Circuit on Monday indicated it had 72 hours to review the mandamus petition, which it termed "an extraordinary remedy."
A 3rd Circuit panel consisting of Judges Cheryl Ann Kraus, David Porter and Arinna J. Freeman ruled Malik was not entitled to emergency relief since he has the option of appealing Dodge's decision.
If developments occur in a case that prevent a court from granting requested relief, the case must be dismissed as moot, the panel explained.
Malik in 2020 was among the first inmates at Loretto to request compassionate relief due to his exposure to the COVID-19 virus, noting he had many health problems.
His petition was not granted and he eventually contracted COVID-19.
After recovering from the virus, he withdrew his request for compassionate release as moot.
Malik on Monday, as suggested by the 3rd Circuit, filed an appeal to Dodge's opinion.