Wind farm operator wants judge to toss civil lawsuit
By Phil Ray, pray@altoonamirror.com
POSTED: June 19, 2008
HOLLIDAYSBURG — The owner of a 100-acre wind farm in Juniata Township, Blair County, and three townships in Cambria County has asked a judge to dismiss a civil lawsuit filed by property owners complaining of noise and vibrations from the giant turbines.
Allegheny Ridge Wind Farm LLC of Philadelphia said a court ruling in favor of a husband and wife complaining about the noise could “open the judicial floodgates to any neighbor to sue a wind farm after construction based on the wind farm’s mere existence.”
Dr. Todd Stull and his wife, Jill, in early May filed a lawsuit asking the court to order Gamesa Energy USA LLC, which installed the turbines, and Allegheny Ridge, which owns the farm, to abate the noise and vibrations coming from the blades on each of the 40 turbines.
The Stulls live a half-mile from the wind farm and said they moved to that area almost 20 years ago “seeking a quiet, rural setting where they could raise their children, enjoy the outdoors and retire to a tranquil setting.”
The wind farm began operation a year ago, and the sound of the blades cutting through the air, they said, sound like an aircraft and has interfered with their sleep, causing “stress and anxiety.”
In the past two days, Gamesa and Allegheny Ridge have filed petitions seeking court dismissal of the lawsuit, denying that the wind farm is noisy and stating that the company has governmental approval to operate the farm.
No date has been set for a hearing, but the companies are asking Blair County President Judge Jolene Kopriva to dismiss the lawsuit as unfounded.
In papers filed Wednesday by Pittsburgh attorney Richard W. Hosking on behalf of Allegheny Ridge, the company contends that the noise level from the farm amounts to 70 decibels, which “equates to the noise of an average radio or normal street noise.”
The company said when Gamesa and Allegheny Ridge went before Juniata Township supervisors and state authorities for permission to erect the wind farm, nobody protested.
Now, Hosking said, after 40 windmills have been constructed, the Stulls have brought a lawsuit complaining of the noise and vibrations.
Hosking said the company always admitted there would be noise.
The Stulls disagreed, stating that Gamesa and Allegheny — a fully owned subsidiary of Philadelphia-based Gamesa USA — when approaching government, said there would be no noise. This is why the Stulls never protested the turbines.
In addition, Allegheny Ridge said governmental approval to install the turbines bars lawsuits based on a claim that they are a public nuisance.
“The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has repeatedly held that, where a project has been authorized by a legislatively mandated process, it cannot be the subject of a public nuisance claim,” Hosking said.
Juniata Township, he stated, passed three ordinances regulating — and approving — the windmills.
Mirror Staff Writer Phil Ray is at 946-7468.
Member Comments
View Comments: | 1-5 | Post a comment
|
Green43la
|
|
|---|---|
|
06-22-08 12:31 PM
|
I would like Gamesa to come and lease my ground, we have over 100 acres in a good area for wind, how can i get a hold of them?
|
|
cowher12
|
|
|
06-20-08 2:36 PM
|
Gamesa will win they are all in this together with Fast Eddy running the show. Wind Farms are a sham...Once the tax credits go away they wont even be able to break even and the citizens will be stuck looking at these nasty hunks of steel and metal on their beautiful mountainsides.
|
|
RonKamzelski
|
|
|
06-19-08 5:07 PM
|
The EPA set guidelines of 55 dB(A) or less during the daytime and 45 dB(A) or less at night, at noise sensitive locations. The EPA further indicated their guidelines should be viewed as maximum tolerable levels rather than levels of negligible impact. In areas such as this, where existing background noise levels are low, a lower noise criterion would be considered appropriate. The allowable noise level for wind energy facilities at night should be no higher than 35 dB(A) or 40 dB(A); or alternatively, 5 dB(A) over background ambient noise level. This maximum represents the recognized international standard for wind energy facility noise based on wind energy noise regulations from around the world.
|
|
salaman
|
|
|
06-19-08 2:46 PM
|
Gamesa told me at a public forum that they want to be "good neighbors". They also claimed that their turbines are no louder than a fridge....about 45db.I guess things have changed. Me thinks the fridge has a bad compressor.
|
|
97neon
|
|
|
06-19-08 6:26 AM
|
Townships beware!
|